Awards & Recognition

Novelty awards: when fun categories strengthen a program

A joyful team celebrates a victory by holding a trophy under a blue sky in Mexico.

Photo by Cristian Aragón on Pexels

Novelty awards sit in an uncomfortable middle ground. Used well, a fun category gets the whole room laughing and makes a presentation night feel like it belongs to the people in it. Used carelessly, it embarrasses a recipient, dilutes serious recognition, or signals that the organising committee didn't take the evening seriously. The difference between those two outcomes isn't the category itself. It's the design decisions around it.

What novelty awards actually do

A well-placed novelty award does something a straight performance category can't: it names a personality, a habit, or a moment that everyone already privately agrees on. The person who always brings the loudest snack bag to training. The player who has argued every close call for three consecutive seasons. The committee member who has sent 400 emails about the canteen roster. When the award names something real, the room responds with recognition rather than confusion.

That recognition has real value. It tells people that someone was paying attention to the texture of the season, not just the scoreboard. It's a form of belonging. And it creates a moment of shared humour that holds the room's attention in a way that a string of achievement categories often can't.

The risk is that the category crosses from affectionate to pointed. A novelty award that calls out a genuine failure, embarrasses someone in front of their family, or is transparently a dig dressed as a joke will be remembered long after the trophy night ends. The test is simple: would the recipient be comfortable if the category name were printed in the club newsletter? If the answer is no, the category needs reworking.

Where to place novelty awards in the running order

Placement matters as much as the award itself. Novelty categories dropped in the middle of serious recognition can derail the room's focus just as the evening is building momentum. Opening with them risks setting a tone that undermines everything that follows.

The two spots that work best are the very beginning of the night or the transition point just before the final major award. Early placement treats novelty awards as an icebreaker: they loosen up the room, signal that the evening will be relaxed, and don't compete with the serious recognition still to come. Placing one just before the final award works as a pressure valve, giving the room a laugh before the weight of the main presentation.

What doesn't work is scattering novelty categories throughout the program. If a fun award follows immediately after a scholarship or best-and-fairest announcement, it blunts the significance of what just happened. If you're thinking through tiered award structures for your club or organisation, treat novelty categories as a separate tier entirely and position them accordingly rather than mixing them into the ranked hierarchy.

How many is too many

One or two novelty awards per night is a generous ceiling. At three, the novelty category starts to feel like its own program within the program. At four or more, the message to recipients of serious awards is that the organising committee values comedy as highly as achievement.

The number also depends on the event's overall length. A two-hour presentation night with 20 categories can carry two novelty awards without noticing them. A 45-minute junior sports presentation can carry one. The ratio of fun to formal matters, and erring on the side of fewer is almost always the right call. It's also worth reviewing your full category list regularly: an audit that trims redundant serious categories will often reveal that a novelty award added years ago has become stale. The award categories that nobody wins are often novelty categories that outlived their moment.

Wording and presentation on the night

The way a novelty award is presented matters as much as the category name. A dry reading of the recipient's name without context lands flat. A brief story, told warmly by the MC or the presenter, is what turns a novelty category into a genuine moment.

Keep it short. Thirty seconds of setup, the name, the award, done. The longer the build-up, the higher the expectation, and novelty categories rarely survive high expectations. The trophy or plaque itself should be recognisably different from the serious awards: different material, smaller format, or clearly playful engraving. Handing out an identically formatted award for "Most Likely to Bring Weather to Training" and "Best and Fairest" confuses both categories.

The engraving wording needs care too. The category name can be playful, but the recipient's name and year should still be treated with the same precision you'd apply to any other award. Getting someone's name wrong on a novelty trophy doesn't become funny because the category is funny. It's still an error, and it still reflects on the club.

Novelty awards in corporate settings

Corporate recognition programs can use novelty awards effectively, but the threshold for care is higher than it is in a sporting club. Colleagues have employment relationships, power dynamics, and HR considerations that a footy club doesn't. A novelty award that names a personality quirk in a small sports club reads as fond. The same award in a workplace, handed to a junior employee by senior management, can read as mockery.

In a corporate context, the safest novelty categories are ones the recipient nominates themselves for, or ones that recognise collective habits rather than individual quirks. "First one to claim the good meeting room" only works if the entire team is competing for the joke. Categories that single one person out for something they might actually be self-conscious about don't belong in a formal corporate awards program, regardless of how warmly the presenter delivers them.

If your organisation runs a broader recognition program, it's worth reading about discretionary awards as a comparison point. Discretionary categories share some of the same flexibility as novelty awards but carry a different weight, and understanding the distinction helps you decide which format fits a given moment.

The line between inclusive and exclusive

The best novelty awards are ones where the whole room feels in on the joke. The recipient laughs loudest. Everyone nods because they've all witnessed the thing being recognised. That's inclusive.

The worst novelty awards are ones where a small group is laughing at someone who isn't quite sure whether to smile. That's exclusive, and it doesn't belong at any recognition event, regardless of the category's intent.

Before finalising any novelty category, ask two people outside the organising committee whether the award reads as affectionate or pointed. If they hesitate, rename it or cut it. The presentation night has one job: to make people feel good about belonging to the club or organisation. Novelty awards can serve that job. They just need to be chosen as carefully as the ones that do it seriously.