Special commendation awards exist for a simple reason: pre-set categories don't cover everything. A player who shows extraordinary courage through injury, a staff member who quietly holds a team together during a crisis, a student who transforms from disengaged to outstanding mid-year. None of those stories fit neatly into "best and fairest" or "most improved". A special commendation award is what you reach for when the standard program runs out of words for what someone actually did.
Used well, they're among the most powerful awards on any program. Used poorly, they create awkward questions about process and fairness. The difference comes down to a few decisions made well before presentation night.
What sets a special commendation apart
A special commendation is not a consolation prize. It's not a category invented to include someone who missed out elsewhere. Those are fundamentally different things, and conflating them is the fastest way to drain the award of meaning.
The defining feature of a genuine special commendation is that it recognises something specific and unrepeatable. The recipient did something, or endured something, or contributed something that the existing program simply didn't anticipate. That specificity is what gives the award its weight.
Compare that to a discretionary category added at the last minute because a committee member likes a particular person. The object on the shelf might look identical. The room reads the difference immediately.
When a special commendation is the right call
Not every situation that "doesn't fit" deserves a special commendation. The threshold should be high. These are the scenarios where it genuinely earns its place.
- Courage under adversity. An athlete who competes through serious personal hardship, a volunteer who steps in during an organisational crisis, a student who re-engages after a significant setback.
- Contribution that spans categories. Someone whose impact crossed multiple teams, departments or age groups, making them ineligible for any single existing award but clearly deserving recognition.
- A singular event. A one-off achievement that the program has no precedent for, such as a junior coach building an entire new program from scratch in a single season.
If the reason doesn't pass that test, don't create the award. The guidance on discretionary awards covers the boundary between genuine recognition and ad-hoc addition in more detail.
How often is too often
Once per program cycle is the right target. Twice is acceptable if both situations are genuinely distinct and both meet the threshold above. Three or more in a single presentation night and the award stops reading as special. It reads as a catch-all.
If you're regularly reaching for special commendations to cover gaps, the real problem is that your standard award categories need an audit. Some programs accumulate redundant categories over time, while simultaneously missing the situations that actually matter. Fixing the category structure solves both problems at once. The process for auditing categories that nobody wins is a practical place to start.
Deciding who gets one
Special commendations should be committee decisions, not individual ones. One person nominating in secret and presenting a surprise award without any process behind it creates exactly the kind of favouritism perception that destroys trust in a program.
The minimum viable process: a written nomination that describes the specific reason, reviewed by at least two other people before approval. That's it. It doesn't need to be a full judging panel. It just needs more than one person agreeing that the threshold is met.
Document the reason clearly. When someone asks "why did they get that?", the answer should be ready, specific and consistent. Vague answers like "they just do so much" don't hold up under scrutiny and they devalue the award retrospectively.
Presenting the award on the night
Special commendations work best when presented last, or close to last. They're not warm-up material. The specific nature of the recognition means they carry the most narrative weight on the program, and that weight lands harder when the audience is already in the room emotionally.
The presenter should speak first, before naming the recipient. Two or three sentences that describe what the person did, without naming them yet, creates the best possible moment. Everyone in the room starts scanning through possibilities. When the name lands, it lands with full attention.
Keep the speech under 90 seconds. The specificity of the award does the work. Over-explaining dilutes it.
Choosing the right award object
A special commendation shouldn't use the same trophy format as the standard categories. It doesn't need to be more expensive. It needs to look distinct. A different material, a different shape, or a different size signals to everyone in the room that this is a different kind of recognition.
Glass and crystal awards suit occasions where the commendation carries a formal or weighty tone. Timber plaques work well for community and volunteer contexts, where warmth fits better than formality. Acrylic works in settings where the club or organisation has a contemporary visual identity.
The engraving matters more on a special commendation than on almost any other award, because the reason for the award is specific. "Special Commendation" as the only text tells the recipient almost nothing a year later. Include the season or year, one line describing what they did, and their name. That's the minimum. The award should be readable as a standalone story when the recipient pulls it off a shelf in ten years.
What to avoid
Don't use a special commendation to soften the blow of a contested result elsewhere on the program. If two people genuinely tied for best and fairest and the committee picked one, the other person doesn't need a consolation commendation. That's uncomfortable for the recipient and transparent to the room. The guidance on consolation awards covers how to handle runners-up recognition properly.
Don't announce the award without telling the recipient in advance. Surprises feel generous in theory and awkward in practice. The recipient doesn't know whether to have a speech ready. Their family doesn't know to be there. Give them 24 hours' notice at minimum, with a request for discretion until the night.
Don't name the category "Special Commendation" if the reason is specific enough to warrant its own title. "Courage Award", named for the season and the circumstance, carries far more weight than a generic label. The name is part of the recognition.
Recording the award in club history
Special commendations should go into the official record just like any other award. If your club or organisation keeps a roll of honour, a perpetual plaque, or an end-of-season report, the commendation belongs there with the full reason documented.
Awards that exist only in living memory disappear. The whole point of a special commendation is that the contribution was significant enough to step outside the standard program. It deserves the same permanence as the awards that are presented every single year.

